10 Amazing Prime Pantry Toilet Paper for 2024

(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Storables.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)

When it comes to the essential household item of toilet paper, it's crucial to find the perfect balance between quality, affordability, and convenience. As we approach the year 2023, Prime Pantry offers an incredible selection of toilet paper options that meet these criteria and exceed expectations. In this article, we will explore and review the top 10 amazing Prime Pantry toilet paper choices for 2023, providing you with valuable insights and making your shopping experience as smooth as possible.

Charmin Ultra Gentle TP – 18 Mega Rolls

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9.2/10

Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper is a top-quality, dermatologist-tested toilet paper that provides a gentle and soothing experience. Each pack contains 18 Rolls (286 sheets per roll) of Charmin Ultra Gentle, which is equivalent to 72 regular rolls. The toilet paper is clog-safe, septic-safe, and Roto-Rooter approved, ensuring hassle-free maintenance. It is made from responsibly managed forests, reflecting Charmin's commitment to sustainability. With its touch of soothing lotion, it gently cleans even irritated skin, making it perfect for those with sensitive skin. The Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper offers exceptional softness, absorbency, and durability, surpassing other brands in performance. This pack of 3 is a great value for both quality and quantity.

Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper is a top-notch product that delivers on its promise of gentleness, softness, and durability. It offers a luxurious and comfortable experience for those with sensitive skin, without compromising on quality. The pack of 18 Mega Rolls is a cost-effective choice, providing long-lasting convenience and reducing the need for frequent roll changes. While the price may be slightly higher than some alternatives, the superior performance and reliability make it worth the investment. With its commitment to sustainability and responsible sourcing, Charmin sets itself apart as a brand that cares about both its customers and the environment. Highly recommended for those seeking the ultimate gentle and premium toilet paper experience.

Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper – 24 Family Mega Rolls

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper with Cushiony CleaningRipples Texture is a premium quality toilet tissue that offers a gentle and sustainable cleaning experience. With 24 Family Mega Rolls, which is equivalent to 108 regular rolls, this toilet paper is perfect for big families. It is septic-safe, 3x more absorbent, and leaves you comfortably dry, making it ideal for sensitive skin. The toilet paper is made from 100% plant-based fibers and is free of harsh chemicals. Use it along with Cottonelle flushable wet wipes for a refreshing clean. The FSC certification ensures responsible sourcing and prevents deforestation. Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper is a soft and reliable choice for a healthy and comfortable clean.

Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper is a top choice for families looking for a reliable and comfortable toilet tissue. With its cushiony CleaningRipples Texture and 3x more absorbency, it provides a gentle and effective cleaning experience. The FSC certification ensures that it is sourced responsibly, making it a sustainable option. While the product offers exceptional quality, the packaging could be improved to reduce plastic waste. Overall, Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Toilet Paper offers a perfect balance between softness, durability, and environmental responsibility, making it an excellent choice for a refreshing and comfortable clean.

Angel Soft® 4 Mega Rolls = 16 Regular Rolls

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

Angel Soft® Toilet Paper provides a heavenly combination of softness and strength. Each pack contains 4 Mega Rolls, equivalent to 16 regular rolls. The Mega Rolls are long-lasting, so you'll change the roll less frequently. This toilet paper is septic safe and made from sustainably sourced trees. With 320 2-ply sheets per roll, it offers great value for its price. The white toilet paper comes in a pack of 1. Customers rate it at 4.7 out of 5 stars.

Angel Soft® Toilet Paper offers a heavenly combination of softness and strength at a great price. With its long-lasting Mega Rolls, septic-safe design, and sustainably sourced materials, it provides excellent value for your money. While it may not be as soft as some other brands, it still gets the job done efficiently. The majority of customers seem satisfied with its quality and performance. If you’re looking for a reliable and budget-friendly toilet paper option, Angel Soft® is a solid choice.

Amazon Basics Toilet Paper

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper is a cost-effective option for high-traffic bathrooms and families. With 10,500 sheets of 2-ply toilet paper in each pack, this product offers exceptional value. Each roll contains 4.3 times more sheets than a regular roll, providing convenience and long-lasting use. The toilet paper is soft, strong, and septic-safe, making it suitable for different environments. If you're a fan of Angel Soft, you'll appreciate the quality of this Amazon Basics toilet paper. It offers a balance between thickness and durability, ensuring a comfortable user experience. The Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper is a smart choice for those looking for a reliable and affordable option.

The Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper offers excellent value for money and is a suitable choice for high-traffic bathrooms and families. With each pack containing 10,500 sheets, you won’t have to worry about running out frequently. While it may not be as long-lasting as some other brands, it provides a balance between thickness, durability, and affordability. The toilet paper is soft, strong, and septic-safe, ensuring a comfortable and convenient user experience. Whether you’re in need of toilet paper for your home or office, the Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper is a reliable option that won’t break the bank.

Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

Enjoy superior comfort with Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper. This pack contains 18 rolls of Charmin Ultra Soft Family Mega Roll toilet paper, providing 313 sheets per roll. With our unique cushiony touch, this toilet paper offers a softer way to get clean without compromising on strength. Each Charmin Family Mega Roll contains 25% more sheets compared to Charmin Mega Roll. It is clog-safe and septic-safe, approved by Roto-Rooter. Choose Charmin Ultra Soft for a luxurious bathroom experience.

Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper offers superior comfort and strength while providing a luxurious bathroom experience. With its unique cushiony touch, it is a favorite choice for many households. The 18 rolls in each pack last long and offer great value for the price. These clog-safe and septic-safe rolls flush well, making them practical and convenient. Although some users found the fit in standard TP holders to be a bit tight, the overall performance and quality of this toilet paper outweigh any minor drawbacks. If you value both comfort and cleanliness, Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper is an excellent choice for your family.

Angel Soft Toilet Paper, 48 Mega Rolls

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

Angel Soft Toilet Paper offers a heavenly combination of softness and strength in every roll. With 48 Mega Rolls equal to 192 Regular Rolls, you'll have long-lasting supply. Made from sustainably sourced trees, it is septic safe and provides great value at a great price. Each roll contains 320 2-ply sheets. The white color and dimensions of 15.13Lx10.13Wx7.60H make it a convenient choice. Customers have rated it 4.8/5, praising its absorbency, softness, and value for money. While it may require using slightly more compared to some other brands, it is better for the plumbing system. Overall, Angel Soft is a consistently good product that offers quality and affordability.

Angel Soft Toilet Paper is a reliable option that balances softness, absorbency, and value for money. While it may not be as wide or heavy as some other brands, it offers a convenient pack size and is septic safe. The paper breaks down well in plumbing systems, making it a suitable choice for those concerned about the environment. Its consistent performance and thick yet non-clogging nature have garnered positive reviews. Although it may require using slightly more compared to certain brands, its quality and affordability make it a worthwhile purchase.

Cottonelle Ultra Clean Toilet Paper

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

Upgrade your bathroom experience with Cottonelle Ultra Clean Toilet Paper. This toilet paper features the Active CleaningRipples Texture that removes residue, odor-causing bacteria, and is gentle on sensitive skin. With 24 Family Mega Rolls, each roll containing 388 sheets, you'll have a long-lasting supply. The 1-ply toilet paper is septic-safe and 3x stronger, ensuring clean hands while wiping. Cottonelle is FSC certified, guaranteeing responsibly sourced materials that are 100% plant-based and free of harsh chemicals. Combine with Cottonelle flushable wet wipes for a refreshing clean. With a customer rating of 4.8/5, this toilet paper is a popular choice for those looking for a high-quality and eco-friendly option.

Cottonelle Ultra Clean Toilet Paper is an eco-friendly and high-quality option for your bathroom. With its Active CleaningRipples Texture, it effectively removes residue and odor-causing bacteria, providing a fresh and clean experience. The toilet paper is soft, strong, and absorbent, ensuring comfort and durability. While there are some shortcomings with the CleaningRipples texture and strength, the overall value and quality make it a solid choice. With 24 Family Mega Rolls, you’ll have a long-lasting supply that is FSC certified and septic-safe. Upgrade your bathroom experience with Cottonelle Ultra Clean Toilet Paper.

Amazon Presto! Ultra-Strong Toilet Paper – 24 Rolls

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

Introducing the Amazon Brand – Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll 2-Ply Toilet Paper! This toilet paper comes in a pack of 24 mega rolls, equivalent to 96 regular rolls. It is up to 80% thicker and stronger than the leading 1,000 count brand, offering a luxurious and absorbent toilet paper experience. The septic-safe bath tissue is perfect for any household. With the option to restock through your Alexa device, you'll never run out of toilet paper again. Customer reviews praise its thickness, softness, and absorbency. Although it may not fully replace the popular Charmin Ultra Strong, it provides peace of mind and is significantly more affordable. Get the Amazon Brand – Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll 2-Ply Toilet Paper today and experience top-quality bathroom hygiene!

The Amazon Brand – Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll 2-Ply Toilet Paper offers an excellent combination of thickness, softness, and absorbency. While it may not completely replace the luxurious feel of Charmin Ultra Strong, it provides a highly satisfying experience at a fraction of the cost. The option to restock via Alexa device ensures you never run out of toilet paper. Some customers have reported slight quality issues and delivery problems, but overall, the Presto toilet paper remains a reliable choice. Enjoy top-quality bathroom hygiene with the Amazon Brand – Presto! 308-Sheet Mega Roll 2-Ply Toilet Paper!

Scott Trusted Clean Toilet Paper

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

Introducing Scott Trusted Clean Toilet Paper, the perfect choice for those who value long-lasting quality and sustainability. This 1-ply toilet paper is not only septic-safe and clog-free but also lasts longer and dissolves faster than other brands. Made from responsibly sourced materials, Scott toilet paper is 100% biodegradable and features recyclable packaging. The 32 regular rolls provide excellent value, ensuring you won't run out for months. Designed for sensitive pipes, this thin tissue is essential for maintaining plumbing health. Though not the softest option, it offers unbeatable value. With Scott Trusted Clean Toilet Paper, you can trust in a reliable brand that delivers quality and affordability.

Scott Trusted Clean Toilet Paper is the ultimate choice for eco-conscious consumers who value both quality and affordability. This septic-safe, 1-ply toilet paper offers exceptional value with 32 regular rolls that last for months. While it may not be the softest option available, its thin design ensures it won’t clog sensitive pipes. Additionally, its sustainably sourced materials and recyclable packaging make it an environmentally friendly choice. If you’re looking to save money without compromising on functionality, Scott Trusted Clean Toilet Paper is the perfect solution. Trust the brand that generations have relied on and make your purchase today.

Amazon Brand – Presto! 2-Ply Toilet Paper

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.5/10

The Amazon Brand – Presto! 2-Ply Toilet Paper offers excellent quality, softness, and value. Each package includes 24 Mega Rolls, equivalent to 120 regular rolls, ensuring you won't run out anytime soon. The toilet paper leaves less lint behind and is septic-safe. It compares favorably to leading ultra-premium soft brands in laboratory testing. The Amazon Brand – Presto! is a great alternative if you are a fan of Charmin Ultra Soft toilet paper. The longer-lasting Mega Rolls and convenient restocking via Alexa make it a hassle-free choice. The product comes with a satisfaction guarantee, allowing you to get a refund within a year if you're not satisfied.

The Amazon Brand – Presto! 2-Ply Toilet Paper offers an excellent combination of quality, softness, and value. With its long-lasting Mega Rolls, septic-safe formula, and satisfaction guarantee, it provides a hassle-free and reliable option for your toilet paper needs. While it may not match the softness of top premium brands, it offers a cost-effective alternative without compromising on performance. Whether you’re stocking up for your household or using it in commercial settings, the Amazon Brand – Presto! toilet paper is a worthy choice that delivers on its promises. Say goodbye to frequent restocking and enjoy a comfortable bathroom experience with this reliable and affordable toilet paper option.

Buyer's Guide: Prime Pantry Toilet Paper

• Know your toilet paper needs: Before purchasing toilet paper from Prime Pantry, consider the number of people in your household, their bathroom habits, and how frequently you need to restock. This will help you determine the appropriate quantity to buy.
• Consider the ply: Toilet papers come in different ply options, typically ranging from one to four ply. Higher ply means more layers and a potentially softer and more absorbent toilet paper. Evaluate your preferences and priorities to choose the ply that suits you best.
• Check the roll count: Take note of the number of rolls that come in each package. Larger packages often offer a better value for money, but ensure you have enough storage space before going for bigger quantities.
• Read customer reviews: Prime Pantry provides detailed customer reviews for each product. Take some time to read through these reviews to gather insights about the quality, softness, durability, and overall satisfaction of other customers with the specific toilet paper you are interested in.
• Compare prices: Examine the prices of different toilet paper options on Prime Pantry. Consider the price per roll or price per sheet to find the most economical option.
• Select a reputable brand: Prominent brands often have established their reputation for a reason. Opting for a well-known brand may increase the likelihood of choosing a quality product.
• Check for eco-friendly options: If you prioritize environmentally-friendly products, look for toilet papers made from recycled materials or those certified by recognized eco-labels. Pay attention to product descriptions or certifications provided by Prime Pantry.
• Check for special features: Some toilet papers have unique features such as lotion-infused, aloe vera enhanced, or extra softness. If you have specific requirements or preferences, look for products with these additional characteristics.
• Consider delivery time: Prime Pantry usually provides an estimated delivery time for each product. Check when you'll receive your toilet paper, so you can plan ahead and ensure you don't run out.
• Balance price and quality: While budget considerations are important, it's crucial to strike a balance between the price and the quality of toilet paper. Saving a few bucks may not be worth it if the toilet paper lacks the necessary softness or durability.