15 Best Maytag Ice Maker Replacement for 2024

(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Storables.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)

Introducing the 15 Best Maytag Ice Maker Replacement for 2023. If you're in need of a high-quality ice maker replacement for your Maytag appliance, look no further. In this comprehensive guide, we have curated a list of the top 15 ice maker replacements that will guarantee efficient ice production and superior cooling performance. Whether you're a homeowner or a business owner, investing in a reliable Maytag ice maker replacement is crucial to ensure you never run out of ice. Explore our selection and find the perfect replacement for your needs in 2023.

Model-Specific Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement by Supplying Demand

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Supplying Demand D7824706Q 10549201 10563707 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement is a model-specific ice maker designed to replace your existing ice maker. It is important to disconnect your appliance before servicing and troubleshoot any potential issues such as high freezer temperature or clogged water filter. The replacement ice maker is compatible with major brands, but always verify fitment with your specific model. With its easy installation process and compatibility, this ice maker provides a convenient solution for ensuring a steady supply of ice in your refrigerator.

The Supplying Demand D7824706Q 10549201 10563707 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement provides a reliable solution for replacing your old ice maker. With its model-specific design and compatibility with major brands, it offers a hassle-free installation process. Customers have praised its exact fit for different refrigerator models, making it a popular choice for replacements. While some users mentioned the need to manually turn off the ice maker in certain cases, it does not overshadow its overall performance. If you’re in need of a high-quality replacement ice maker, the Supplying Demand D7824706Q is definitely worth considering.

Model-Specific Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Replacement by Supplying Demand

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Supplying Demand W10190965 W10190966 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly is a high-quality replacement part for refrigerators. It is designed for specific model side-by-side refrigerators and is not universal. The ice maker features a heated mold with a flat pin plug and comes with a video guide to help you find the model number. It is important to disconnect the power and water supply before servicing. With easy installation and compatibility with major brands, this ice maker assembly is a convenient solution for those in need of a replacement. The product comes in Supplying Demand packaging and is highly rated by customers.

The Supplying Demand W10190965 W10190966 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly is a reliable replacement part for specific model refrigerators. It offers easy installation and compatibility with major brands, making it a convenient solution for those in need of a new ice maker. The heated mold ensures efficient ice making, and the product comes with a video guide to help you find the correct model number. While it may not fix all ice-making issues and does not include a bail arm, this ice maker assembly receives high ratings from satisfied customers. Overall, it is a great option for anyone seeking a reliable replacement ice maker for their refrigerator.

Affordable and Reliable Replacement Icemaker for Amana Fridges

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The NEW part IM900 Refrigerator Icemaker is a replacement unit designed to fit specific Whirlpool manufactured refrigerators including Roper, Kitchenaid, Amana, Maytag, Jenn Air, Magic Chef, and some Sears Kenmore models. It is not compatible with GE, Hotpoint, and Frigidaire refrigerators. The icemaker is easy to install and has received positive reviews from customers. It is a generic unit, but works effectively and costs significantly less than other models on the market. Installation by a handyman can be done at a reasonable cost, making it an affordable solution for replacing a broken or malfunctioning ice maker. Overall, this icemaker offers a great value for its price.

The NEW part IM900 Refrigerator Icemaker is a reliable and affordable alternative for replacing a broken or malfunctioning ice maker. It is easy to install and fits perfectly in Amana fridges. With positive customer reviews and a significantly lower price compared to other models, it is a recommended option to consider. However, it is important to note that some customers reported receiving incomplete parts, which could be an inconvenience. Overall, this icemaker offers good performance and represents a cost-effective solution for keeping your refrigerator well-stocked with ice. Give it a try and enjoy chilled beverages once again!

Ice Maker Replacement Kit for Kenmore Maytag Refrigerator

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 7/10

The Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Replacement Kit is a complete kit designed for Kenmore Maytag refrigerators. It includes 2 harnesses and comes with clear instructions for easy installation. With a 1-year warranty, this replacement kit ensures lasting performance. The dimensions of the kit are 14.00Lx4.00Wx4.00H. Customers have rated it at 4.3 out of 5 stars.

The Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Replacement Kit provides a convenient solution for those needing to replace their ice maker in Kenmore or Maytag refrigerators. While it may require some part swapping and the ice tray coating may flake off over time, the overall installation is easy and the performance is reliable. Customers have reported good results and have appreciated the money-saving aspect compared to other options. If you’re in need of an ice maker replacement, this kit is worth considering.

ClimaTek Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker for Maytag D7824703

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9.5/10

The ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker for Maytag D7824703 is a brand new ice maker designed to replace Part # D7824703. This top-quality ClimaTek replacement is built to last and does not include unnecessary harnesses, making it a cost-effective choice. It is compatible with Maytag and other refrigerators and freezers. The ice maker has received a customer rating of 5.0/5, with reviewers praising its performance and stating that it works just as described.

The ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker for Maytag D7824703 is a reliable and cost-effective replacement for your faulty ice maker. With its top quality build and compatibility with various brands, you can trust it to produce ice consistently. The absence of unnecessary harnesses ensures that you only pay for what you actually need. Overall, it is highly recommended for anyone looking to replace their Maytag ice maker with a durable and efficient alternative.

ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 7.5/10

The ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker is a top-quality replacement part for Maytag refrigerators. This brand new icemaker is built to last and provides a reliable solution for your ice-making needs. It comes with the base icemaker kit, eliminating the need for unnecessary harnesses. With its easy installation process, you can have ice in no time. The ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker works with various Maytag models, making it a versatile choice. However, some customers have experienced issues with the ice production, with slower ice-making cycles compared to the original icemaker. Nonetheless, for its quality and affordability, this ClimaTek icemaker receives a score of 7.5 out of 10.

The ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker offers a cost-effective solution for replacing your Maytag icemaker. While it may have some limitations in terms of ice production speed and customer service, it provides a reliable ice-making performance. The easy installation process and compatibility with various Maytag models make it a convenient choice for homeowners. With its top-quality construction and affordable price, the ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker is a great option to consider if you need a replacement icemaker for your Maytag refrigerator.

Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Compatible with Maytag Refrigerator

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.5/10

The Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker is a compatible replacement for Maytag refrigerators. It comes with a 1-year warranty and a money-back guarantee. The ice maker is designed to replace multiple models, including 4317943, PS358591, and W10632400. With fast shipping and easy installation, this ice maker is a good buy for those in need of a replacement. Just be aware that the new harness is too short, so it's best to keep the old one. Overall, customers have given this ice maker a rating of 4.4 out of 5.

The Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker offers a convenient and reliable solution for replacing your Maytag refrigerator’s ice maker. With a compatible design and a warranty, you can trust in its quality. The fast shipping and easy installation add to its appeal. However, the short length of the new harness could be an inconvenience. Overall, this ice maker is a great option for those in need of a replacement, earning a score of 8.5 out of 10.

Compatible Icemaker Kit for Refrigerator

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

Don't spend a fortune on replacing your refrigerator or freezer when all you need is a replacement icemaker. The Compatible Icemaker Kit is the cost-effective solution to get your appliance up and running again. Whether you're a DIY enthusiast or prefer professional repair, this icemaker is easy to install. It is designed to fit perfectly with the listed models, ensuring compatibility. With its high customer rating, this kit has received positive reviews for its functionality, ease of installation, and performance. However, there have been a few negative opinions about the quality of the product. Overall, the Compatible Icemaker Kit provides an affordable and efficient solution for your refrigerator needs.

The Compatible Icemaker Kit offers an affordable and convenient solution for replacing your refrigerator’s icemaker. It is easy to install and fits perfectly with the listed models. This cost-effective option saves you from spending hundreds on a new appliance. However, a few customers have reported concerns about the product’s quality. Overall, it is a reliable choice for those looking for a budget-friendly alternative to keep their refrigerator functioning properly.

Refrigerator Icemaker for Whirlpool Maytag

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

Looking for a replacement icemaker for your Whirlpool refrigerator? Look no further! The Refrigerator Icemaker for W10884390 Whirlpool Maytag is an excellent choice. This icemaker comes with everything you need for easy installation, including a cord, shut off arm, and mounting bracket. With its eight-cube capacity, you'll never run out of ice again. It is also a replacement for various part numbers, ensuring compatibility with your appliance. Customers have praised its simplicity and durability, making it an excellent investment. The only downside is that it may not produce ice as fast as some would like. Overall, this icemaker is a reliable choice for keeping your drinks chilled and refreshing.

The Refrigerator Icemaker for W10884390 Whirlpool Maytag is a reliable replacement icemaker that offers simplicity and durability. With its included accessories and compatibility with various Whirlpool models, it ensures easy installation and a perfect fit. While it may not produce ice as fast as some would prefer, its overall performance and customer satisfaction make it a worthy investment. Say goodbye to running out of ice and hello to refreshing drinks with this reliable icemaker.

Thunder IM900 Refrigerator Icemaker for Maytag Amana PS2121513 AP4135008 + more

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.2/10

The NEW IM900 Refrigerator Icemaker is a versatile replacement option for multiple icemaker models and is compatible with various refrigerator brands. This icemaker is designed as a cost-effective alternative to professional service, allowing you to save money while still enjoying the convenience of ice production in your refrigerator. It comes with testing instructions, making the installation process hassle-free. If you have any questions regarding model compatibility, the manufacturer provides excellent customer support. With its affordable price, ease of installation, and wide compatibility, the NEW IM900 Refrigerator Icemaker is a reliable choice for those in need of a replacement icemaker.

Overall, the NEW IM900 Refrigerator Icemaker offers a practical and affordable solution for replacing icemakers in various refrigerator models. With its wide compatibility and ease of installation, this product allows you to enjoy the convenience of ice production without the need for professional assistance. The inclusion of testing instructions ensures a smooth installation process, even for those with limited technical expertise. While specific specifications are not provided, the positive customer reviews indicate its effectiveness and reliability. If you’re in need of a reliable and cost-effective icemaker replacement, the NEW IM900 Refrigerator Icemaker is worth considering.

Supplying Demand Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Supplying Demand W10873791 W10760070 Refrigerator 10 Cube Flex Tray Ice Maker Replacement is a great option for anyone looking to replace their old or faulty ice maker. This replacement ice maker is designed to work with a variety of different refrigerator models, and it offers a convenient and reliable way to make ice in your home. The ice maker is made from durable materials that are built to last, and it has a sturdy and well-designed housing that keeps the ice maker securely in place. The ice maker itself has a 10 cube flex tray design, which allows you to make a large amount of ice at once. It is an affordable and durable solution for anyone looking to replace their ice maker.

The Supplying Demand W10873791 W10760070 Refrigerator 10 Cube Flex Tray Ice Maker Replacement is an excellent choice for anyone looking to replace their old or faulty ice maker. It offers a convenient and reliable way to make ice in your home, and it is easy to install and made of durable materials. The 10 cube flex tray design allows you to make a large amount of ice at once, making it ideal for households with high ice consumption. Additionally, its energy-efficient design helps save on energy costs. Despite some potential issues with ice cube thickness and the plastic ice tray, this replacement ice maker provides an affordable and durable solution for those in need.

Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Owigift Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement is the perfect aftermarket part to replace the ice maker in Whirlpool, Maytag, Kenmore, and Amana refrigerators. With new bail arm, frame, motor head, case cover, and mounting hardware included, it provides a high level of compatibility and convenience. Note that it does not come with wire harness, bucket, or water valve. The package includes all the necessary components for easy installation, making it a great replacement option for a broken or malfunctioning ice maker. With a customer rating of 4.5 out of 5, this replacement ice maker is highly recommended by satisfied users.

The Owigift Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement is a reliable and efficient option for those in need of a replacement ice maker for Whirlpool, Maytag, Kenmore, or Amana refrigerators. With easy installation and high compatibility, it provides a cost-effective solution for fixing a broken or malfunctioning ice maker. While some users experienced minor issues such as slower ice production or installation difficulties, overall, this replacement ice maker delivers satisfactory performance. So, if you’re looking for an affordable and reliable replacement ice maker, the Owigift Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement is worth considering.

Maytag, Jenn-Air, and KitchenAid Refrigerator Ice Maker

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 7.5/10

The Refrigerator Ice Maker Compatible with Maytag MFD2561HES, Maytag MBF2258WES2, Maytag MSD2454GRQ, Jenn-Air JFC2089HPY, KitchenAid KBFS22EWMS4 Refrigerators is a premium quality replacement part for compatible models. Made from high-quality material, it has been well-tested by the manufacturer to ensure durability and reliability. This aftermarket ice maker fits perfectly in the listed models, providing an easy installation process. Please note that this is a generic product and not covered under any OEM manufacturer's warranty. It is recommended to reuse the cord from your old icemaker as the cord is not included with this product. Overall, this ice maker offers a convenient solution for replacing or upgrading your refrigerator's ice maker.

The Refrigerator Ice Maker Compatible with Maytag MFD2561HES, Maytag MBF2258WES2, Maytag MSD2454GRQ, Jenn-Air JFC2089HPY, KitchenAid KBFS22EWMS4 Refrigerators is a reliable and convenient replacement part for compatible models. Its premium quality and easy installation make it a great choice for replacing or upgrading your refrigerator’s ice maker. However, the lack of information on specifications may be a drawback for some users. With a score of 7.5 out of 10, this ice maker provides a satisfactory solution for ensuring a steady supply of ice in your refrigerator.

Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker for Maytag 61005508

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker for Maytag 61005508 is a top-quality replacement part built to last. It is designed to replace Part # 61005508 and is compatible with Maytag and other brands. This base icemaker kit provides excellent functionality without the need for unnecessary harnesses. With dimensions of 6.00Lx10.00Wx8.00H, it offers a compact and convenient size. This ClimaTek ice maker is a brand new product that ensures high performance and durability for your refrigerator or freezer.

The ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker for Maytag 61005508 is a reliable and efficient replacement part that offers excellent value for money. With its top-quality construction, it provides long-lasting performance and ensures that your refrigerator or freezer functions optimally. This icemaker kit is specifically designed to replace Part # 61005508, eliminating the need to purchase unnecessary harnesses. Compatible with Maytag and other brands, it offers versatility and convenience. Overall, the ClimaTek Upgraded Refrigerator/Freezer Icemaker is a practical choice for those in need of a reliable replacement for their existing icemaker.

Whirlpool Refrigerator Ice Maker Kit

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9.2/10

The Whirlpool 4396418 Ice Maker Kit is a high-quality replacement part commonly used with Whirlpool, KitchenAid, Maytag, and Amana brands. This OEM Authorized part is designed to be used on bottom freezer refrigerators and does not include an ice bucket/bin. With its perfect fit and genuine Whirlpool quality, it's an easy and reliable solution for replacing a defective ice maker. Installation is simple and can be done in just a few minutes, making it an ideal choice for both DIY enthusiasts and those with less mechanical experience. The ice maker works great and has received positive reviews from customers. This Whirlpool ice maker kit is a must-have for anyone in need of a reliable replacement ice maker.

The Whirlpool 4396418 Ice Maker Kit is an excellent replacement option for Whirlpool, KitchenAid, Maytag, and Amana refrigerators. It is highly praised for its perfect fit, genuine Whirlpool quality, and ease of installation. With positive reviews from customers, it has proven to be a reliable solution for anyone in need of a new ice maker. The kit’s ability to accommodate different setups adds to its versatility. The only downside is that it does not include an ice bucket/bin. Overall, if you’re looking for a dependable replacement ice maker, the Whirlpool 4396418 is a great choice.

Buyer's Guide: Maytag Ice Maker Replacement

Are you tired of waiting for your ice maker to produce ice? Is your Maytag ice maker giving you trouble and in need of a replacement? We've got you covered! In this comprehensive buyer's guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know before purchasing a new Maytag ice maker replacement. From features to consider, installation tips, and common concerns – we'll address it all. So let's dive right into it!

Key Features to Consider

When searching for a Maytag ice maker replacement, keep these important features in mind:

• Ice Production Capacity: Consider the amount of ice you typically need. Look for ice makers with a suitable capacity to meet your family or business's demands.
• Ice Production Speed: If you frequently require a large quantity of ice, opt for a faster ice maker to avoid any waiting time during batch production.
• Ice Cube Size and Shape: Some ice makers offer options to choose different ice cube sizes or shapes, such as bullet or crescent. Pick one that suits your preferences or fits best in your glassware.
• Energy Efficiency: Look for energy-efficient models with high efficiency ratings to reduce electricity consumption and save on your utility bills.
• Noise Level: Consider the noise level of the ice maker, especially if you plan to install it in a shared or living space. Quieter models ensure a peaceful environment.
• Ease of Installation: Check for user-friendly ice makers that come with clear installation instructions, required hardware, and even installation kits to simplify the process.
• Maintenance and Cleaning Ease: Look for ice makers that offer easy access for cleaning and maintenance. Some models include self-cleaning functions or removable parts for hassle-free upkeep.
• Compatibility: Ensure compatibility with your Maytag refrigerator model. Check the ice maker’s dimensions, required power supply, and connection type to ensure a perfect fit.

Installation Tips

Here are some helpful tips for installing your new Maytag ice maker replacement:

• Read the Manual: Familiarize yourself with the installation instructions provided by the manufacturer. This will ensure a smoother process and help avoid any mishaps.
• Power Down and Disconnect: Before installing the new ice maker, turn off the power to your refrigerator and carefully disconnect any existing ice maker.
• Prepare the Space: Clear the area where the ice maker will be installed, ensuring there is enough clearance for proper ventilation and maintenance.
• Follow the Plumbing Requirements: If your ice maker requires a water supply connection, make sure to follow the instructions precisely. Improper installation may lead to leaks or malfunctioning.
• Test for Leaks: After installing the new ice maker, check for any water leaks during the initial use. This avoids potential damage to your refrigerator or surrounding areas.
• Properly Align and Secure: Ensure the ice maker is properly aligned with your refrigerator and securely fastened to avoid vibrations or noise issues.
• Allow for Proper Air Circulation: Leave sufficient space around the ice maker for proper air circulation and ventilation, preventing overheating and ensuring optimal performance.