10 Incredible Toaster Oven Tray Replacement For 2024

(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Storables.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)

Introducing the 10 Incredible Toaster Oven Tray Replacement for 2023. If you own a toaster oven and are in need of a new tray, look no further. In this article, we will explore the top ten tray replacements that are not only functional but also durable and stylish. Whether you are a cooking enthusiast or simply need a reliable tray for your daily baking needs, this comprehensive list is designed to help you make an informed decision. From non-stick options to versatile designs, these toaster oven tray replacements are sure to enhance your culinary experience in the coming year. Stay tuned to discover the perfect addition to your kitchen arsenal.

TeamFar Stainless Steel Compact Toaster Oven Pan Tray 8×10.5×1

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.5/10

The TeamFar Stainless Steel Compact Toaster Oven Pan Tray Ovenware Professional is a high-quality and healthy choice for your toaster oven needs. Made of 430 pure stainless steel, this tray is free from toxic coatings and prevents coating chips from falling into your food. It is heavy-duty and durable, with a sturdy feel that resists warping. The smooth roll edge and superior mirror finish make it easy to clean. The deep full sides prevent food from going everywhere. The pan comes in a metal silver color and has the dimensions of 10.30Lx7.70Wx1.30H with a size of 8''x10.5''x1''. Customers have given it a rating of 4.6 out of 5.

The TeamFar Stainless Steel Compact Toaster Oven Pan Tray Ovenware Professional is an excellent choice for those in need of a reliable and healthy toaster oven pan. Its high-quality stainless steel construction and lack of toxic coatings make it a safe and durable option. The smooth finish and deep sides enhance its functionality, while the easy-clean design adds convenience. Despite some concerns regarding warping and size, overall, this pan delivers on its promises. Whether you’re reheating or cooking, this tray’s performance will not disappoint.

G&S Non-Stick Toaster Oven Cookie Pan – 8.5 x 6.5 inches – Gray

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.5/10

The G & S Metal Products Company HG56 OvenStuff Non-Stick Toaster Oven Cookie Pan is a high-quality bakeware option made with durable steel construction. Its non-stick coating eliminates the need for cooking spray or oil, ensuring healthier meals and easy cleanup. With a compact size of 8.5 inches by 6.5 inches, it is perfect for single servings or a few cookies. The pan fits perfectly in most household toaster ovens and conventional ovens. Made in the USA, this pan offers standard sizing and even heating for optimal cooking results. Customers have praised its heavy-weight design and durability. The only downside is the lack of a small handle for easy maneuvering. Overall, this pan is an excellent addition to any kitchen.

The G & S Metal Products Company HG56 OvenStuff Non-Stick Toaster Oven Cookie Pan is a reliable and efficient bakeware option. Its non-stick coating and high-performance steel construction ensure even heating and easy food release. With its compact size and standard sizing, it fits perfectly in most toaster ovens. While the lack of a small handle and the need for immediate hand-drying after washing are minor drawbacks, the overall quality and performance of this pan make it a worthwhile purchase. Improve your baking experience with this American-made pan that offers professional results at a consumer-friendly price.

TeamFar Pure Stainless Steel Toaster Oven Pan Tray Ovenware

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The TeamFar Pure Stainless Steel Toaster Oven Pan Tray is a compact and heavy-duty ovenware that offers easy cleaning and healthy cooking. Made of high-grade 430 pure stainless steel, this pan is free from toxic coatings and materials, ensuring the safety of your food. With a smooth roll edge and superior mirror finish, it is easy to clean and maintains a beautiful appearance. The deep full sides prevent food from spilling and allow for an even heat distribution. Its small size of 7''x9.3''x1'' makes it ideal for toaster ovens. Customers have praised its quality and functionality, although some mentioned that it may not fit all toaster oven models.

The TeamFar Pure Stainless Steel Toaster Oven Pan Tray is a great addition to any kitchen with a toaster oven. Its high-quality construction, easy maintenance, and healthy cooking capabilities make it a reliable choice. While it may not fit all toaster oven models, it offers excellent value for its price. However, customers who prefer handwashing may find it slightly challenging to clean. Overall, this pan is recommended for its durability and functionality.

P&P CHEF Toaster Oven Tray and Rack Set

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The P&P CHEF Toaster Oven Tray and Rack Set is a high-quality stainless steel baking pan with a cooling rack. It is designed to fit small ovens and is perfect for single person use. The tray and rack are made of non-toxic stainless steel with no additional materials or toxic teflon coating, providing a healthier cooking experience. The tray is solidly constructed with a thick gauge stainless steel, while the roasting rack is waved by stainless steel lines. Both parts are rust-free and durable for years. With a smooth rolled edge and strongly weaved cooling rack, this set allows for even baking and prevents food from falling through. The mirror finish makes the small baking sheet easy to release food, and both parts are dishwasher safe for easy cleaning. The set includes a baking pan measuring 10.4 x 8 x 1 inch and a rack measuring 9.7 x 7.3 x 0.6 inch, suitable for most regular toaster ovens.

The P&P CHEF Toaster Oven Tray and Rack Set offers a great solution for those looking to upgrade their small oven or enjoy single person cooking. Made of high-quality stainless steel, this set is built to last and provides a healthy cooking experience. The even baking and perfect results achieved with the waved cooling rack and smooth rolled edge are definite highlights. While there have been a few reports of warping when heated, this seems to be an isolated issue. Overall, this set is a reliable and convenient addition to any kitchen.

Nonstick Toaster Oven Pans – 11 Inch Baking Sheets

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

The 11 Inch Baking Sheets for Oven by Shinsin are high-quality and durable pans made of heavy carbon steel. With their nonstick coating, these sheets ensure quick and effortless food release. They are designed for even heat distribution and come in a perfect size for baking cookies, lasagna, pumpkin, and more. The rimmed border prevents spills while allowing ample airflow for even baking. These baking sheets are made of food-safe materials and are oven-safe up to 400°F. They are easy to clean and guaranteed not to warp or bend. With a sleek gold color, they add a touch of elegance to your baking experience.

The 11 Inch Baking Sheets for Oven by Shinsin are a fantastic addition to any kitchen. With their nonstick coating and even heat distribution, baking becomes a breeze. The durable construction ensures these pans will last, and the rimmed border prevents spills and promotes even baking. They are the perfect size for a variety of dishes and are easy to clean. While there may be a slight color difference from the picture, this does not affect their performance. Overall, these baking sheets are a great investment for any baking enthusiast.

Cuisinart Toaster Oven Baking Pan

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Cuisinart AMB-TOBCS Toaster Oven Baking Pan is a heavy-gauge aluminumized steel pan designed for even heating. It features a non-stick interior and exterior for easy release and cleanup. With dimensions of 11.2 inches (L) x 10.7 inches (W) x 0.8 inches (H), it is recommended to measure the interior of your toaster oven to ensure a proper fit. This baking pan is dishwasher safe, adding to its convenience. The silver-colored pan is made by Cuisinart, a reputable manufacturer. It has received positive reviews for its durability and non-stick coating. However, some customers have complained about difficulties in cleaning and occasional warping. Overall, it is a reliable and high-quality pan, especially for toaster ovens.

The Cuisinart AMB-TOBCS Toaster Oven Baking Pan is a reliable and high-quality option for those in need of a toaster oven pan. Its heavy gauge aluminumized steel construction ensures even heat distribution, resulting in consistent cooking. The non-stick interior and exterior make it easy to release food and clean up afterwards. Although a few customers have experienced difficulties in cleaning and occasional warping, the majority of reviews praise its durability and non-stick performance. With its decent size and dishwasher-safe design, this baking pan is a practical addition to any toaster oven. Whether you’re baking, heating leftovers, or cooking snacks, the Cuisinart AMB-TOBCS Toaster Oven Baking Pan is a versatile and reliable choice.

9 Inch Small Toaster Oven Pan with Grid Rack and Silicone Mat Set

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The P&P CHEF Mini Stainless Steel Toaster Oven Tray Baking Pan with Cooling Rack is a versatile and convenient bakeware set for your kitchen. Made of pure stainless steel and food-grade silicone, this set is safe to use and easy to clean. The 9-inch baking pan is perfect for one-person use and can also be used as a serving tray or cookie tray. The 8.6-inch baking rack helps with even heating and allows for better air circulation, while the 8.27-inch baking mat provides a non-stick surface for baking and rolling pastry. This set is ideal for cooking, roasting, or cooling and makes a thoughtful gift for your loved ones.

The 9 Inch Small Toaster Oven Pan with Grid Rack and Silicone Mat Set from P&P CHEF is a practical and well-made bakeware set. It offers versatility and convenience for your cooking and baking needs. The high-quality stainless steel and silicone materials ensure durability and easy cleaning. The set’s compact size is perfect for one-person use or small batches. However, the pan sides could be taller for certain recipes, and the cooling rack may be warped. Overall, this set is a great addition to your kitchen and makes a thoughtful gift for anyone who enjoys baking.

Wilton Toaster Oven Baking Sheet Pan & Crisper Tray

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Wilton Perfect Results Toaster Oven Baking Sheet Pan & Crisper Tray is the perfect solution for baking small batches or meals in your toaster oven. You can easily satisfy your cravings for crispy appetizers or French fries with these durable and non-stick pans. The set includes a baking sheet pan and a crisper tray, both of which are dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. With its compact size and convenient nesting design, storage is a breeze. Whether you're baking for everyday meals or special occasions, this Wilton baking sheet and crisper tray set will help you work smarter, not harder.

The Wilton Perfect Results Toaster Oven Baking Sheet Pan & Crisper Tray is a great addition to any kitchen. It offers convenience, durability, and versatility in a compact package. The non-stick coating ensures easy cleanup, while the nesting design allows for hassle-free storage. Although it may warp slightly at high temperatures and can dent if mishandled, these minor drawbacks are outweighed by its overall performance. Whether you’re cooking for yourself or a small family, this baking sheet and crisper tray set is perfect for creating delicious meals and snacks. Upgrade your toaster oven baking experience with the Wilton Perfect Results set and enjoy the benefits of working smarter, not harder.

Cuisinart Toaster Oven Tray Replacement

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Stainless Steel Cuisinart Toaster Oven Tray Replacement is a high-quality baking tray designed specifically for the Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven TOA-060 & TOA-065. Made with durable stainless steel, this tray is built to withstand high temperatures and is dishwasher safe for easy cleaning. It is the perfect replacement for your old or damaged tray, allowing you to continue baking and cooking with ease. The tray fits perfectly and performs just as well as the original, with a smooth non-stick surface. It is versatile enough for all your baking and cooking needs, from roasting vegetables to baking cookies. With a customer rating of 4.6/5, this Cuisinart toaster oven tray replacement is a great choice for any kitchen.

The Stainless Steel Cuisinart Toaster Oven Tray Replacement is a reliable and high-quality product that offers a perfect fit for the Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven. It is durable, easy to clean, and versatile for all your baking and cooking needs. While it may not be an exact match in size and some trays arrived with minor issues, overall, it provides good value for the price. If you’re looking to replace your old or damaged tray, this Cuisinart toaster oven tray replacement is a great choice.

P&P CHEF 9" Stainless Steel Toaster Oven Pan & Rack Set

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.5/10

The Mini Toaster Oven Pan with Rack & Mat Set by P&P CHEF is the perfect addition to your small toaster oven. This 3-in-1 value set includes a 9 x 7 x 1 inch stainless steel toaster oven pan, an 8.6 x 6.2 x 0.6 inch cooling rack, and an 8.6 x 6.2 inch silicone mat. Made of pure stainless steel and silicone, this set is both healthy and durable. The smooth edges and proper weight of the pan and rack ensure comfortable handling and prevent accidents. The 1-inch deep pan increases capacity and prevents messy spills, while the 0.6-inch rack feet lift your food and allow for even roasting and cooling. The superior mirror surface of the pan and rack resists sticking and makes cleaning a breeze. The nonstick silicone mat is heat proof, grease proof, and water proof, providing a convenient replacement for parchment paper. With its compact size and versatile design, this set is perfect for small toaster ovens and one-person use. Whether you're baking cookies or cooking bacon, this Mini Toaster Oven Pan with Rack & Mat Set is sure to meet your needs.

The Mini Toaster Oven Pan with Rack & Mat Set by P&P CHEF is a highly versatile and durable addition to any small toaster oven. With its value set of three essential baking tools, you’ll have everything you need for various cooking and baking tasks. The pure stainless steel and silicone materials ensure a healthy and long-lasting product. The smooth edges and proper weight provide comfort and safety during use. Additionally, the nonstick baking mat and superior mirror surface make cleaning effortless. While there have been a few reports of warping at high temperatures, this is a minor concern compared to the overall quality and functionality of the set. Overall, the Mini Toaster Oven Pan with Rack & Mat Set is a fantastic choice for individuals with small toaster ovens who want to expand their cooking possibilities.

Toaster Oven Tray Replacement Buyer's Guide

Are you tired of your old and worn-out toaster oven tray? Maybe it's lost its non-stick coating or has become scratched and dingy over time. Fret not! We have the ultimate guide to help you find the perfect replacement tray for your toaster oven. Say goodbye to subpar toasted treats and hello to crispy, evenly cooked meals with a brand new tray!

Factors to Consider

When searching for a toaster oven tray replacement, keep these important factors in mind to ensure you make the right choice:

1. Compatibility: Not all toaster oven trays are universal, so it's crucial to find one that fits your specific toaster oven model. Measure the dimensions of your old tray or consult your toaster oven's manual for the appropriate size.
2. Material: Toaster oven trays can be made of various materials, including stainless steel, aluminum, or porcelain-coated steel. Each material has its pros and cons, such as durability, heat distribution, and ease of cleaning. Consider your cooking needs and preferences before making a decision.
3. Non-Stick Coating: A non-stick coating is essential for easy food release and hassle-free cleaning. Look for trays with a high-quality non-stick coating to prevent your meals from sticking and to simplify the cleaning process.
4. Heat Resistance: Ensure the replacement tray you choose can withstand high temperatures without warping or discoloring. You don't want your tray to lose its shape or affect the taste of your food due to heat sensitivity.
5. Ease of Cleaning: Cooking can be messy, so it's important to find a tray that is simple to clean. Dishwasher-safe trays can save you precious time and effort, but some may require handwashing. Consider your cleaning preferences and available kitchen resources.
6. Versatility: Some replacement trays come with additional features, such as a broiling rack or raised edges to prevent spills. Determine if any of these features align with your cooking style and needs.
7. Price: Replacement trays can range in price, depending on the material, brand, and additional features. Set a budget and consider the value for money each tray offers along with its durability and performance.