Articles
11 Amazing Ice Maker Replacement for 2024
Modified: January 8, 2024
Looking for the best ice maker replacement options? Explore our top 11 picks for 2023 and enjoy hassle-free ice making at home.
(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Storables.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)
Introducing the ultimate guide to finding the perfect ice maker replacement for 2023. In this comprehensive overview, we have curated a list of 11 incredible ice maker alternatives that are sure to meet all your needs. Whether you're looking for a compact and portable option for your outdoor adventures or a high-capacity machine for hosting large gatherings, our curated selection has you covered. Discover the latest advancements in ice maker technology and explore a variety of features, designs, and budgets to find the ideal replacement for your icy refreshments. Let's dive into the world of 11 amazing ice maker replacements for 2023.
Overall Score: 8.5/10
The Supco 8 Cube Ice Maker Replacement Kit is the perfect solution for replacing your in-door ice maker. It is compatible with various refrigerator models from Whirlpool, Kenmore, and KitchenAid. The kit includes all the necessary components for installation, such as mounting hardware and brackets. With its high-quality parts, the RIM597 meets or exceeds OEM specifications. It is designed for 8 cube units and offers widespread use, replacing 2000 different ice maker models. The Supco ice maker kit is reliable and easy to install, making it an excellent choice for anyone in need of a replacement ice maker.
Key Features
- Modular ice maker for Whirlpool, Kenmore, and Kitchen Aid
- Highest quality parts that exceed OEM specifications
- Compatible with 2000 different refrigerator models
- Comes with mounting hardware and instructions
- Includes heavy-duty rake and extra-wide stripper board
Specifications
- Dimension: 11.25Lx5.00Wx4.50H
Pros
- Easy to install with included instructions
- Reliable performance and wide compatibility
- Cost-effective solution compared to professional installation
- Works well with various refrigerator brands
Cons
- Does not include the sensor arm as advertised
- Paint on the ice tray may flake off over time
- Excessive ice production can lead to jamming
The Supco 8 Cube Ice Maker Replacement Kit offers a convenient and affordable solution for replacing in-door ice makers. With its high-quality parts, wide compatibility, and ease of installation, it is a reliable choice for anyone in need of a new ice maker. The only drawbacks to consider are the absence of the sensor arm and the potential for paint flaking on the ice tray over time. Overall, this kit delivers excellent value for the price, making it a highly recommended option.
Overall Score: 9.2/10
Looking for an excellent replacement for your old ice maker? The Supco Modular Ice Maker Replacement Kit is here to save the day. With high-quality parts that meet or exceed OEM specifications, this ice maker kit is designed to work with existing wiring and plumbing, making it compatible with popular brands like Kenmore, Whirlpool, KitchenAid, Roper, and Sub-Zero. It's the perfect solution for your ice-making needs. The kit includes everything you need for a hassle-free installation. With a dimension of 11.00Lx5.00Wx4.50H, it's compact and easy to fit. Customers love its universal fit and great performance. However, be careful about water level adjustments and check if the electrical harnesses are included.
Key Features
- Universal ice maker replacement
- Highest quality parts
- Widespread use
- High compatibility
Specifications
- Dimension: 11.00Lx5.00Wx4.50H
Pros
- Excellent replacement for various brands
- Meets or exceeds OEM specifications
- Easy installation and compatibility with existing wiring
- Compact size
Cons
- Water level adjustment required
- Electrical harnesses may not be included
The Supco Modular Ice Maker Replacement Kit is a reliable and efficient solution for replacing your old ice maker. With its universal fit and high-quality parts, it’s designed to provide you with a seamless ice-making experience. Customers have praised its performance and compatibility, making it a popular choice among users. Just be sure to adjust the water level properly and check if the electrical harnesses are included. Overall, this ice maker kit offers great value for its price and is definitely worth considering if you’re in need of a replacement.
Overall Score: 8.5/10
The KITCHEN BASICS 101 Ice Maker Replacement is a premium quality aftermarket part that is designed to replace ice makers in Electrolux, Frigidaire, Gibson, Kelvinator, Westinghouse, and other refrigerators. It is made from durable high-quality material and exceeds OEM requirements. The replacement part is compatible with various ice maker models and comes with a money-back guarantee. With easy installation and a one-year warranty, this ice maker replacement provides a reliable solution for ice-making needs. It has received positive customer ratings and reviews, with users praising its compatibility, ease of installation, and performance.
Key Features
- Premium quality aftermarket ice maker replacement
- Compatible with select Electrolux and Frigidaire refrigerator models
- Made from durable high-quality material
- Money-back guarantee and one-year warranty
Specifications
- Color: Kitchen Basics 101
- Dimension: 12.20Lx6.60Wx5.40H
Pros
- Compatible with various refrigerator brands
- Durable and well-tested construction
- Money-back guarantee for customer satisfaction
- Simple and hassle-free installation
Cons
- Some users experienced early malfunction
- Ice production may be slow for some users
The KITCHEN BASICS 101 Ice Maker Replacement offers a reliable solution for those in need of a replacement ice maker for their Electrolux or Frigidaire refrigerator. With its durable construction and compatibility with various refrigerator models, this aftermarket part delivers consistent ice-making performance. While some users experienced early malfunctions and noted slower ice production, the overall customer reviews are positive. The easy installation process and the added assurance of a one-year warranty make this ice maker replacement a practical choice. If you’re looking for a cost-effective and dependable replacement, the KITCHEN BASICS 101 Ice Maker Replacement is worth considering.
Overall Score: 8.5/10
The KITCHEN BASICS 101 WR30X10093 Ice Maker Kit Replacement is a high-quality ice maker compatible with various GE, General Electric, Hotpoint, Kenmore, Sears, and RCA refrigerators. It comes with all the necessary components for a hassle-free installation, including the ice maker, wire adapter, power cords, end mounted fill cups, fill tube, and instruction sheet. This ice maker kit is a direct replacement for many GE models and fixes common issues like the ice maker not making ice, not dispensing ice, or leaking. It is UL/CSA approved for safe operation and offers a 1-year warranty. With positive customer reviews and a high customer rating, this ice maker kit is a reliable and affordable solution for your ice-making needs.
Key Features
- Replaces a variety of GE ice maker models
- Compatible with various GE, Hotpoint, Kenmore, Sears, and RCA refrigerators
- Includes all necessary components for installation
- Fixes common ice maker issues like not making ice or leaking
- UL/CSA approved for safe operation
- Comes with a 1-year warranty
Specifications
- Dimension: 10.00Lx5.50Wx5.00H
Pros
- Direct replacement, easy to install, works perfectly
- Universal ice maker compatible with different model refrigerators
- Produces a significant amount of ice
- Affordable alternative to exact replacement
- Comes with all necessary components for installation
Cons
- Cycle time is slightly slower than the original ice maker
- Ice cubes are slightly smaller than the original
- Occasional jamming and ice overflow issues
The KITCHEN BASICS 101 WR30X10093 Ice Maker Kit Replacement is a reliable and cost-effective solution for replacing the ice maker in your GE refrigerator. With its compatibility with various models and easy installation process, it offers convenience and functionality. While it may have some minor drawbacks with cycle time and ice cube size, the overall performance and positive customer reviews make it a worthwhile purchase. If you’re looking for a durable and efficient ice maker kit that won’t break the bank, this is a solid option to consider.
Overall Score: 8.5/10
The 241798231 241798224 Ice Maker Assembly by SupHomie is a reliable replacement part for Frigidaire refrigerators. It effectively replaces multiple part numbers and is compatible with various brands including Frigidaire, Gibson, Kelvinator, Tappan, Crosley, and more. This ice maker assembly is designed to fix common problems such as ice maker not producing ice or not dispensing ice. It comes with a new built-in harness for easy installation. The housing is made of durable materials and features a mechanical motor for longer-lasting performance. With a one-year warranty and excellent customer support, the SupHomie Ice Maker Assembly ensures customer satisfaction.
Key Features
- Replaces multiple part numbers
- Compatible with various brands
- Fixes common ice maker problems
- High-quality materials and mechanical motor
- One-year warranty and customer support
Specifications
- Color: As Pictured
Pros
- Replaces multiple part numbers
- Compatible with various brands
- Easy installation with built-in harness
- Durable housing and mechanical motor
- One-year warranty and customer support
Cons
- Some customers reported loud operation
- No installation instructions included
The 241798231 241798224 Ice Maker Assembly by SupHomie is a reliable and cost-effective replacement part for Frigidaire refrigerators. It provides a solution to common ice maker problems and is easy to install. The durable construction and mechanical motor ensure long-lasting performance. The one-year warranty and customer support offer peace of mind to customers. However, some users have reported loud operation and the lack of installation instructions. Overall, this ice maker assembly is a great option for restoring the functionality of your refrigerator’s ice maker.
Overall Score: 8/10
The Supplying Demand D7824706Q 10549201 10563707 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement is a model-specific ice maker designed to replace your existing ice maker. It is important to disconnect your appliance before servicing and troubleshoot any potential issues such as high freezer temperature or clogged water filter. The replacement ice maker is compatible with major brands, but always verify fitment with your specific model. With its easy installation process and compatibility, this ice maker provides a convenient solution for ensuring a steady supply of ice in your refrigerator.
Key Features
- Compatible with major brands
- Model-specific design
- Easy installation process
Specifications
- Color: White
- Dimensions: 11.25Lx4.50Wx4.75H
Pros
- Exact fit for various refrigerator models
- Great replacement for Viking and Maytag fridges
- Easy plug-in installation
- Sturdy and durable design
Cons
- Wire used to turn off ice is too thin in some cases
- Slightly slower at producing ice
- May require reusing some old parts
The Supplying Demand D7824706Q 10549201 10563707 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement provides a reliable solution for replacing your old ice maker. With its model-specific design and compatibility with major brands, it offers a hassle-free installation process. Customers have praised its exact fit for different refrigerator models, making it a popular choice for replacements. While some users mentioned the need to manually turn off the ice maker in certain cases, it does not overshadow its overall performance. If you’re in need of a high-quality replacement ice maker, the Supplying Demand D7824706Q is definitely worth considering.
Overall Score: 8/10
Upgrade your refrigerator with the New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid. This high-quality ice maker is compatible with multiple brands and is designed to work as good as or better than the original part. With a package weight of 3.55 pounds, it's lightweight yet sturdy. However, please note that this is not an original part, so it's important to confirm the model before making a purchase. Enjoy the convenience of an ice maker in your home without the hassle of buying ice trays! Buy the New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid and never worry about running out of ice again.
Key Features
- -Compatible with Amana, Jenn Air, Kenmore, Magic Chef, Maytag, Roper
- -Not an original part, please confirm the model before purchasing
- -Package weight: 3.55 pounds
Specifications
Pros
- +Great value and works as good or better than the original ice maker
- +Easy setup with helpful You Tube videos for installation
- +Includes metal bar for ice production (metal bar not included)
- +Perfect fit as a replacement for old ice maker
- +Improved ice cube taste compared to previous ice maker
- +Fixes issues with peeling coating and worn out gears on old ice maker
Cons
- -Risk of flooding if ice maker mechanism jams
- -Short water filling spout may require modification to avoid spillage
- -May require adjustments to water line for proper water flow
- -Coating on ice tray may melt if no ice is present during heater cycle
The New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker for Whirlpool Kenmore Kitchenaid is a reliable replacement option for your refrigerator’s ice maker. It offers great value and performs as well as or better than the original part. With easy setup and helpful installation videos available, you can quickly start enjoying the convenience of a working ice maker. However, be cautious of potential flooding issues if the ice maker mechanism jams. Additionally, some adjustments may be needed to ensure proper water flow. Overall, this ice maker offers an affordable and effective solution for upgrading your refrigerator’s ice production.
Overall Score: 8.5/10
The Supplying Demand 243297609 243297613 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement is a model-specific ice maker that is not universal. It is compatible with French door refrigerators and comes with a cube flex tray and a pin wire harness. Before installing, make sure to disconnect the power and water supply. If the ice maker is not making ice, check the freezer temperature, water filter, thermostat, and water pressure. The part is compatible with major brands, but it's essential to verify fitment with your specific model. The package includes a video and description to help you find your model number. It is compact with dimensions of 10.25Lx5.00Wx3.00H. With a customer rating of 4.2/5, this ice maker replacement has received positive reviews for its easy installation and perfect fit.
Key Features
- Model specific, not universal
- Cube flex tray with pin wire harness
- Compatible with French door refrigerators
- Disconnect power and water supply before installation
- Verify fitment with specific model
- Compact dimensions of 10.25Lx5.00Wx3.00H
Specifications
- Dimension: 10.25Lx5.00Wx3.00H
Pros
- Easy installation
- Perfect fit for specific models
- Improved ice cube quality
Cons
- Motor may wear out
- May require modifications for installation
The Supplying Demand Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement is a reliable and affordable option for those seeking to fix their ice maker issues. With positive customer reviews praising its easy installation process and perfect fit for specific models, this replacement offers improved ice cube quality and solves common problems such as ice clumps and overflow. While there may be a potential issue with the motor wearing out, the overall performance and value of this replacement make it a worthwhile purchase. Say goodbye to buying bags of ice and enjoy quality ice cubes once again!
Overall Score: 8/10
The Supplying Demand W10190965 W10190966 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly is a high-quality replacement part for refrigerators. It is designed for specific model side-by-side refrigerators and is not universal. The ice maker features a heated mold with a flat pin plug and comes with a video guide to help you find the model number. It is important to disconnect the power and water supply before servicing. With easy installation and compatibility with major brands, this ice maker assembly is a convenient solution for those in need of a replacement. The product comes in Supplying Demand packaging and is highly rated by customers.
Key Features
- Replacement ice maker assembly for specific model refrigerators
- Heated mold with flat pin plug
- Compatible with major brands
- Video guide included for finding model number
- Easy installation
- Comes in Supplying Demand packaging
Specifications
- Color: White
Pros
- High-quality replacement
- Easy installation
- Compatible with major brands
- Comes with video guide
- Heated mold for efficient ice making
Cons
- No bail arm included
- May not fix all ice-making issues
The Supplying Demand W10190965 W10190966 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly is a reliable replacement part for specific model refrigerators. It offers easy installation and compatibility with major brands, making it a convenient solution for those in need of a new ice maker. The heated mold ensures efficient ice making, and the product comes with a video guide to help you find the correct model number. While it may not fix all ice-making issues and does not include a bail arm, this ice maker assembly receives high ratings from satisfied customers. Overall, it is a great option for anyone seeking a reliable replacement ice maker for their refrigerator.
Overall Score: 7/10
The Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Replacement Kit is a complete kit designed for Kenmore Maytag refrigerators. It includes 2 harnesses and comes with clear instructions for easy installation. With a 1-year warranty, this replacement kit ensures lasting performance. The dimensions of the kit are 14.00Lx4.00Wx4.00H. Customers have rated it at 4.3 out of 5 stars.
Key Features
- 626640 Ice Maker Replacement Kit For Kenmore Maytag Refrigerator
- Complete Kit 2 harnesses
- Instruction Included
- 1 Year Warranty
Specifications
- Dimension: 14.00Lx4.00Wx4.00H
Pros
- Easy to install
- Exact fit for Kenmore Elite fridge
- Comes with a warranty
- Saves money compared to other options
Cons
- May require part swapping with original unit
- Coating on ice tray may flake off
The Edgewater Parts 626640 Ice Maker Replacement Kit provides a convenient solution for those needing to replace their ice maker in Kenmore or Maytag refrigerators. While it may require some part swapping and the ice tray coating may flake off over time, the overall installation is easy and the performance is reliable. Customers have reported good results and have appreciated the money-saving aspect compared to other options. If you’re in need of an ice maker replacement, this kit is worth considering.
Overall Score: 8/10
The Edgewater Parts 626662 Refrigerator Ice Maker Kit is a compatible replacement for Whirlpool refrigerators. It is designed to replace multiple part numbers and comes with a 1-year warranty. The kit includes everything you need for installation, but it is important to check that your model is listed in the description before purchasing. Customers have generally had positive experiences with this ice maker, with many praising its ease of installation and performance. However, a few customers did experience issues with the product not working or encountering difficulties during installation. Overall, the Edgewater Parts 626662 Refrigerator Ice Maker Kit is a reliable option for replacing a faulty ice maker in your Whirlpool refrigerator.
Key Features
- 626662 Refrigerator Ice Maker Kit For Whirlpool Refrigerator
- Replaces multiple part numbers
- 1 Year Warranty
Specifications
- Dimension: 144.00Lx5.00Wx4.00H
Pros
- Easy installation
- Good performance
- Compatible replacement for multiple part numbers
- 1-year warranty
Cons
- Some customers experienced issues with functionality
- Instructions could be more clear
The Edgewater Parts 626662 Refrigerator Ice Maker Kit offers a convenient and reliable solution for replacing a faulty ice maker in your Whirlpool refrigerator. With its compatibility with multiple part numbers and a 1-year warranty, it provides peace of mind and assurance of quality. While some customers did encounter issues with functionality and found the instructions lacking clarity, overall, the ice maker has received positive reviews for its easy installation and good performance. If you’re in need of a replacement ice maker, the Edgewater Parts 626662 Refrigerator Ice Maker Kit is definitely worth considering.
Buyer's Guide: Ice Maker Replacement
ULTRA-COOL ICE FOR HOT SUMMER DAYSLooking to replace your ice maker? Look no further! We've got you covered with an expert buyer's guide that will help you find the perfect ice maker replacement. Whether you're a frozen beverage enthusiast, a cocktail connoisseur, or simply someone who loves to chill with a refreshing glass of ice-cold water, this guide will steer you in the right direction.
Key Considerations
Before diving into the exciting world of ice maker replacement, there are some key factors you should consider. These considerations will help you find the ideal ice maker to suit your needs:
- Space: Measure the dimensions of the area where your new ice maker will be placed. Ensure you have enough space to accommodate the replacement model without any issues.
- Capacity: Assess the amount of ice you typically use or need on a daily basis. Consider your family size, entertaining habits, or commercial requirements. Opt for a replacement model that meets your ice production needs.
- Types of Ice: Identify the specific type of ice you prefer. From classic cubes to crescent-shaped or nugget ice, there are various options available. Choose an ice maker replacement that produces the ice shape you desire.
- Installation Requirements: Determine whether you prefer a freestanding or built-in ice maker replacement. Freestanding units offer flexibility while built-in models seamlessly blend into your kitchen or bar area.
- Energy Efficiency: Check the energy consumption of the replacement ice maker. Look for models with energy-saving features to reduce utility costs and minimize environmental impact.
- Extra Features: Consider additional features that enhance convenience and usability. Features like automatic shut-off, self-cleaning functionality, or adjustable ice thickness can elevate your ice-making experience.
Maintenance and Care
To keep your ice maker replacement running smoothly and extend its lifespan, it's essential to perform regular maintenance and care. Here are some tips to keep your new ice maker in tip-top shape:
- Cleaning: Regularly clean the ice maker's interior with a mixture of warm water and mild detergent. Rinse thoroughly to remove any soap residues.
- Filter Replacement: If your ice maker has a water filter, replace it as recommended by the manufacturer. This ensures the production of clean and fresh-tasting ice.
- Defrosting: If your ice maker accumulates excess frost, defrost it using the defrost function or manually by emptying the ice bin and allowing it to thaw. Wipe off any remaining moisture before restarting the unit.
- Air Vents: Keep the air vents clean and unobstructed to ensure efficient airflow and prevent overheating. Regularly check and remove any debris or dust buildup to maintain optimal performance.
- Water Supply: Regularly inspect and clean the water supply line to prevent clogs or blockages that may affect ice production. Ensure a steady water flow by removing mineral deposits if needed.
Read also: 11 Amazing Compact Ice Maker for 2024
Frequently Asked Questions about 11 Amazing Ice Maker Replacement For 2024
The lifespan of an ice maker can vary depending on various factors such as usage, maintenance, and the quality of the unit. On average, a well-maintained ice maker can last between 8 to 12 years.
It depends on the space available and the compatibility of the existing connections. Verify the dimensions and installation requirements of both the old and new ice makers to determine if the swap is feasible.
The initial ice production time may vary depending on the specific model. Typically, it takes around 24 to 48 hours for a new ice maker to reach its full ice-making capacity.
Ice makers generally require a standard electrical outlet and a water supply connection. Ensure the electrical and plumbing setups in your home or establishment are compatible with the chosen replacement ice maker.
Installation complexity varies depending on the model and your expertise. Many ice maker replacements come with detailed instructions for DIY installation. However, if you’re unsure or uncomfortable with the process, it’s recommended to hire a professional to ensure a proper installation.
Noise levels can vary between ice maker models and brands. Some produce minimal noise, while others may be slightly more audible during the ice-making process. Check product reviews or specifications to get an idea of noise levels before making a purchase.
While many ice makers come equipped with water filters for improved water quality, they are not always mandatory for operation. Check the manufacturer’s instructions to determine whether your specific ice maker requires a water filter for proper functioning.
Yes, it’s normal for an ice maker to occasionally produce smaller or misshapen ice cubes. Variation in ice size can be caused by factors such as fluctuating temperature, mineral content in the water, or incomplete freezing cycles. These minor variations do not generally affect the ice maker’s overall performance.
It depends on the specific ice maker model and its suitability for outdoor use. While some ice makers are designed for outdoor installations, many are not, as exposure to the elements can impact their performance and lifespan. Always consult the manufacturer’s guidelines before using an ice maker replacement outdoors.
It is not recommended to store ice inside the ice maker for extended periods. Ice may absorb odors or become stale over time. Transfer the ice to a separate container or freezer bags for long-term storage to maintain its quality.
Was this page helpful?
Trust Storables.com for unbiased and honest product reviews. Our reviews are rigorously assessed by our Expert Board Contributors and adhere to strict Editorial Standards. We ensure that each review is transparent and trustworthy, helping you make informed purchasing decisions.
0 thoughts on “11 Amazing Ice Maker Replacement for 2024”