Who Pays Realtor Commission On New Construction

(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Storables.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)

Introduction

Welcome to the exciting world of new construction! Building a new home is an exhilarating experience that offers a fresh start and the opportunity to create your dream home from the ground up. However, navigating the process of buying a newly constructed home can be quite different from purchasing an existing property. One aspect that often raises questions is the payment of realtor commissions.

In the traditional real estate market, the seller typically pays the realtor commission. This means that the seller’s agent and the buyer’s agent are compensated from the proceeds of the sale. However, the dynamics can be different in the case of new construction.

In this article, we will delve into the various commission structures that exist in the real estate industry and explore how they apply to new construction. We will also discuss the pros and cons of different commission payment models and provide some insights into negotiating commissions on new construction deals. So, whether you are a buyer, a seller, or a curious enthusiast, let’s dive in and unravel the intricacies of realtor commission in the world of new construction!

Understanding Realtor Commission

Before we delve into the specifics of realtor commission in new construction, let’s first understand what realtor commission is and how it is typically structured in traditional real estate transactions.

Realtor commission is the fee paid to real estate agents for their services in assisting buyers and sellers throughout the home buying or selling process. The commission is usually a percentage of the final sale price and is divided between the seller’s agent (listing agent) and the buyer’s agent (selling agent).

In a traditional real estate transaction, the seller pays the commission. This means that the commission is deducted from the proceeds of the sale and is typically split between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. The percentage of the commission can vary but is typically around 5-6% of the sale price, with each agent receiving a portion.

The rationale behind this commission structure is that the seller, who benefits from the sale of the property, assumes the responsibility of compensating the agents involved in the transaction.

Now that we have a basic understanding of realtor commission in traditional real estate deals, let’s explore how the commission structure differs in the case of new construction.

Commission Structures in Traditional Real Estate Transactions

In traditional real estate transactions, the commission structure is generally consistent. The seller pays the commission based on the final sale price of the property, and it is divided between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. However, the specific details of the commission structure can vary.

Here are a few common commission structures in traditional real estate:

1. Percentage of Sale Price: This is the most common commission structure, where the commission is a percentage of the final sale price. The percentage can vary, but it is typically around 5-6%.
2. Tiered Commission: In some cases, the commission structure may be tiered, meaning that different percentages apply to different price ranges. For example, there could be a lower percentage for the first $500,000 and a higher percentage for any amount above that.
3. Flat Fee: Instead of a percentage of the sale price, some agents charge a flat fee for their services. This fee is agreed upon between the agent and the client and does not vary based on the sale price.

Regardless of the specific commission structure, the seller generally pays the commission, and it is split between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. However, when it comes to new construction, the commission structure can deviate from this traditional model.

The Unique Case of New Construction

When it comes to new construction, the payment of realtor commissions can vary significantly from traditional real estate transactions. New construction presents some unique considerations that impact how commissions are handled.

One key factor to consider is that builders of new construction projects often work directly with their own sales representatives or onsite agents. These agents are employed by the builder and are responsible for selling the newly constructed homes.

Due to this dynamic, the traditional commission structure, where the seller pays the commission to the buyer’s agent, may not apply. In the world of new construction, there are typically two common commission payment models: the builder-paid commission model and the buyer-paid commission model.

Let’s explore each of these models in more detail.

Builder-Paid Commission Model

In the builder-paid commission model, the builder assumes responsibility for paying the realtor commission. The builder sets aside a certain percentage of the sale price to compensate the buyer’s agent.

Under this model, the buyer’s agent represents the interests of the buyer while working with the builder’s onsite agent. They assist the buyer throughout the home buying process, providing guidance, negotiating terms, and handling paperwork.

The builder-paid commission model is common in many new construction projects, as it allows the builder to attract a larger pool of potential buyers by offering commission incentives to agents. This model can be particularly advantageous for buyers, as they can benefit from the expertise and representation of a realtor without incurring any out-of-pocket expenses.

Buyer-Paid Commission Model

In the buyer-paid commission model, the responsibility for paying the realtor commission falls on the buyer. This means that the buyer’s agent is compensated directly by the buyer, typically in the form of a percentage of the sale price.

Under this model, the buyer’s agent still represents the interests of the buyer and assists them throughout the home buying process. However, the buyer is responsible for covering the cost of the agent’s services.

The buyer-paid commission model is less common in new construction but can occur in certain situations. For example, if a buyer decides to work with a realtor who is not familiar with the builder or the new construction process, they may agree to pay the commission themselves.

Both the builder-paid and buyer-paid commission models have their own advantages and considerations, which we will explore in the next sections.

Builder-Paid Commission Model

The builder-paid commission model is a commonly used method in new construction projects, where the builder assumes the responsibility of paying the realtor commission. Under this model, the buyer’s agent is compensated by the builder for their services in representing the buyer throughout the home buying process.

There are several advantages to the builder-paid commission model:

1. No out-of-pocket expenses for the buyer: By having the builder cover the commission, the buyer does not need to pay any additional fees for the services of a realtor. This can be particularly beneficial for first-time homebuyers or buyers looking to save on upfront costs.
2. Expert representation: When the buyer’s agent is involved in the new construction process, they can provide valuable guidance and expertise. They help navigate the complexities of building a new home, including contract negotiations, upgrades, and inspections. Their knowledge and experience can lead to better outcomes for the buyer.
3. Access to builder incentives: Builders often offer incentives to realtors to encourage them to bring potential buyers to their projects. These incentives can include bonuses, special promotions, or additional commission percentages. By working with a buyer’s agent, the buyer may have access to these incentives, which could result in cost savings or added value for the buyer.

It is important to note that while the builder pays the commission, the buyer’s agent still represents the buyer’s interests throughout the home buying process. They provide valuable advice, negotiate on the buyer’s behalf, and ensure that their best interests are protected.

However, there are a few considerations to keep in mind when it comes to the builder-paid commission model:

• Potential bias: Since the buyer’s agent is being compensated by the builder, there is a possibility of a perceived bias towards the builder’s interests. It is crucial for the buyer’s agent to maintain a strong fiduciary duty to the buyer and ensure that their interests are always prioritized.
• Limited choice: In some cases, the buyer may be restricted to working with the builder’s preferred agents or may have limited options in terms of choosing their own agent. This can be a drawback for buyers who have a specific agent in mind or prefer to work with someone they already have established trust with.

Overall, the builder-paid commission model offers many advantages for buyers, especially in terms of cost savings and access to expert representation. It is important for buyers to understand the specifics of the commission structure before engaging with a buyer’s agent in a new construction transaction.

Buyer-Paid Commission Model

While the builder-paid commission model is more common in new construction, there are instances where the buyer may be responsible for paying the realtor commission. This model is known as the buyer-paid commission model and puts the onus of compensating the buyer’s agent on the buyer themselves.

Here are some key considerations regarding the buyer-paid commission model:

• Direct compensation: Under this model, the buyer compensates the buyer’s agent directly for their services, typically in the form of a percentage of the purchase price. The buyer and the agent must agree on the commission amount and structure before engaging in the home buying process.
• Flexibility in agent choice: With the buyer-paid commission model, buyers have the freedom to choose their own agent, even if they are not affiliated with the builder. This allows the buyer to select an agent they trust and feel comfortable working with throughout the new construction process.
• Perceived objectivity: Since the buyer is directly compensating the buyer’s agent, there may be a perception of more impartial representation. Buyers may feel that their interests are better protected, as the agent is solely working for them and not influenced by any incentives or relationships with the builder.
• Additional cost for the buyer: One of the main drawbacks of the buyer-paid commission model is the additional cost incurred by the buyer. In addition to the purchase price, buyers must factor in the commission fee for their agent. This can be a significant financial consideration, especially for buyers who are already stretching their budget.
• Potential negotiation: In some cases, buyers may have the opportunity to negotiate the commission fee with their agent. However, it’s important to remember that agents provide a valuable service and negotiating too aggressively may result in diminished services or a strained relationship.

While less common, the buyer-paid commission model offers buyers the freedom to work with an agent of their choice and the perceived objectivity that their agent is solely focused on their best interests. However, buyers need to consider the additional financial commitment involved as they will be responsible for compensating their agent directly.

It is essential for buyers to carefully evaluate their budget and priorities before deciding on the commission payment model they are comfortable with. Open communication with potential agents about the commission structure and expectations is also vital in ensuring a successful working relationship.

What Factors Determine the Commission Payment

The commission payment in new construction transactions, whether it is the builder-paid or buyer-paid model, is influenced by several factors. These factors can vary and have an impact on the percentage or amount of the commission. Here are some key factors that determine the commission payment:

1. Sale price: The sale price of the new construction property is a significant factor in determining the commission payment. In most cases, the commission is calculated as a percentage of the sale price. Higher-priced properties generally result in higher commission amounts.
2. Market conditions: The state of the real estate market can also influence the commission payment. In a seller’s market where demand is high and inventory is limited, the commission percentage may be lower since it is easier to sell properties. On the other hand, in a buyer’s market with more properties available, the commission percentage may be higher to incentivize agents to bring buyers to the project.
3. Builder incentives: Builders may offer special incentives to real estate agents to encourage them to bring buyers to their new construction projects. These incentives can include bonuses, higher commission percentages, or other perks. The availability and scope of these incentives can impact the commission payments to the buyer’s agent.
4. Agent qualifications and experience: The qualifications and experience of the buyer’s agent can also play a role in the commission payment. Agents with extensive experience and a successful track record may command higher commission percentages due to the value they bring to the transaction.
5. Negotiation: In some cases, there might be room for negotiation on the commission payment. Both the buyer and the agent can discuss and agree upon a commission structure that is mutually beneficial. However, it’s important to approach negotiations with fairness and understanding, considering the agent’s expertise and the value they bring to the transaction.

It’s worth noting that the specifics of the commission payment, including the percentage or amount, should be established and agreed upon between the buyer and the buyer’s agent before engaging in the new construction transaction. Clear communication and transparency from both parties are crucial to avoid any misunderstandings or conflicts down the line.

Understanding the factors that determine the commission payment can help both buyers and agents navigate the new construction process and ensure a fair and mutually beneficial arrangement.

Pros and Cons of Builder-Paid Commission

The builder-paid commission model in new construction transactions has its own set of advantages and considerations. Let’s explore the pros and cons of the builder-paid commission model:

Pros:

1. No out-of-pocket expenses for the buyer: One of the major benefits of the builder-paid commission model is that the buyer doesn’t have to pay any additional fees for the services of a realtor. The builder covers the commission, making it a cost-effective option for buyers.
2. Expert representation: With the builder-paid commission model, buyers can still benefit from the expertise and guidance of a realtor throughout the new construction process. The buyer’s agent works alongside the builder’s on-site agent, providing valuable advice, negotiating on the buyer’s behalf, and ensuring their interests are protected.
3. Access to builder incentives: Builders often offer incentives to realtors to encourage them to bring buyers to their new construction projects. When working with a buyer’s agent, the buyer may have access to these incentives, which can include bonuses, special promotions, or higher commission percentages. This can result in cost savings or added value for the buyer.
4. Strong builder relationships: Buyer’s agents who frequently work with builders can develop strong relationships with them over time. These relationships can help facilitate smoother transactions and ensure that the buyer’s interests are well-communicated and represented to the builder.

Cons:

• Potential bias: One of the main considerations with the builder-paid commission model is the potential perceived bias towards the builder’s interests. Since the buyer’s agent is being compensated by the builder, there is a possibility that their loyalty may be questioned. However, it is essential for the buyer’s agent to maintain a strong fiduciary duty to the buyer and prioritize their interests above all else.
• Restricted agent choice: In some cases, the buyer may be limited to working with the builder’s preferred agents or have a limited pool of options in terms of choosing their own agent. This lack of flexibility can be a drawback, especially for buyers who have established relationships or preferences for specific real estate agents.
• Perceived limited representation: Some buyers may feel that the buyer’s agent, being compensated by the builder, may not provide fully independent representation. This perception may lead to concerns about whether the agent is truly advocating for the buyer’s interests or prioritizing the builder’s interests.

Ultimately, the pros and cons of the builder-paid commission model should be carefully evaluated by both buyers and agents before engaging in a new construction transaction. Open communication, trust, and transparency are key in ensuring that the buyer’s interests are well-represented throughout the process.

Pros and Cons of Buyer-Paid Commission

The buyer-paid commission model in new construction transactions comes with its own set of advantages and considerations. Let’s explore the pros and cons of the buyer-paid commission model:

Pros:

1. Freedom of agent choice: With the buyer-paid commission model, buyers have the freedom to choose their own real estate agent, even if they are not affiliated with the builder. This allows buyers to select an agent they trust and feel comfortable working with throughout the new construction process.
2. Perceived objectivity: Since the buyer directly compensates the buyer’s agent, there is a perception of more impartial representation. Buyers may feel that their agent is solely focused on their best interests and not influenced by any incentives or relationships with the builder.
3. Flexibility in negotiation: Buyers may have the opportunity to negotiate the commission fee with their agent in the buyer-paid commission model. This can allow buyers to potentially adjust the fee to fit their budget or unique circumstances, resulting in a more customized fee structure.

Cons:

• Additional cost for the buyer: One of the main considerations of the buyer-paid commission model is the additional financial responsibility it places on the buyer. In addition to the purchase price of the new construction property, buyers need to factor in the commission fee for their agent, which can be a significant additional cost.
• Increased upfront expenses: The buyer-paid commission can increase the upfront expenses involved in purchasing a new construction property. This may affect a buyer’s overall budget and financial planning, potentially limiting their options or stretching their resources.
• Harder negotiations: Buyers engaging in the buyer-paid commission model may find negotiations with their agent more challenging. Since the buyer is directly compensating the agent, they may be more inclined to negotiate harder on the commission fee, which can strain the agent-buyer relationship or even lead to diminished services.

When considering the buyer-paid commission model, it is crucial for buyers to carefully evaluate their budget, financial capabilities, and priorities. Open and transparent communication with potential agents about the commission structure and expectations is vital to ensure a successful working relationship.

Ultimately, the buyer-paid commission model offers buyers the freedom of agent choice and the perception of impartial representation. However, buyers need to carefully weigh the additional financial responsibility and consider if it aligns with their financial goals and preferences before opting for this commission payment model.

Negotiating Commission on New Construction Deals

When it comes to new construction deals, there may be opportunities to negotiate the commission with the buyer’s agent. Negotiating the commission fee can be a delicate process that requires open communication and a mutual understanding of the value provided by the agent. Here are some tips for negotiating commission on new construction deals:

1. Research and understand the market:

Before entering into negotiations, it is essential to research and understand the current market conditions. This includes being aware of the average commission rates in the area and any builder incentives that may be available to agents. Knowing this information will give you a solid foundation for productive negotiations.

2. Evaluate agent qualifications and experience:

Consider the qualifications and experience of the buyer’s agent before entering into negotiations. Agents with extensive experience and a successful track record may warrant a higher commission percentage due to the value they bring to the transaction. Evaluate their expertise, market knowledge, and negotiation skills, as these factors can play a role in justifying the commission fee.

3. Communicate your expectations and needs:

Clear and open communication is crucial when negotiating the commission fee. Discuss your expectations and needs with the buyer’s agent, outlining what you are looking for in terms of representation and assistance throughout the new construction process. By expressing your expectations, you can find common ground in negotiating the commission structure.

4. Highlight your loyalty and commitment:

If you have a commitment and loyalty to working with a specific agent, make sure to communicate this during negotiations. Let the agent know that you value their expertise and are committed to working with them throughout the new construction process. This level of dedication may influence the agent’s willingness to negotiate the commission fee.

5. Consider a tiered commission structure:

In some cases, you may consider proposing a tiered commission structure based on the purchase price of the new construction property. This means that the percentage of the commission may fluctuate depending on the price range. A tiered commission structure can be an attractive option for both parties, providing flexibility in negotiations.

6. Assess the overall value provided:

When negotiating the commission fee, focus on the overall value provided by the buyer’s agent. Consider their professionalism, market knowledge, communication skills, and ability to protect your interests throughout the new construction process. Assessing the complete value package can help reach a fair and satisfactory commission agreement.

Remember, negotiating the commission fee is a collaborative effort between the buyer and the agent. Both parties should enter into negotiations with fairness, respect, and the understanding that a successful outcome is beneficial for both sides. Being open to compromise and finding a mutually beneficial agreement will set the stage for a positive working relationship.

Conclusion

Navigating the world of new construction deals and understanding the intricacies of realtor commissions is essential for buyers and sellers alike. Whether it’s the builder-paid commission model or the buyer-paid commission model, each has its own set of advantages and considerations.

For buyers, the builder-paid commission model offers the benefit of expert representation without incurring any out-of-pocket expenses. Buyers can take advantage of their buyer’s agent’s experience, guidance, and negotiation skills to make informed decisions throughout the new construction process. Additionally, access to builder incentives can provide cost savings or added value.

On the other hand, the buyer-paid commission model provides buyers with the flexibility to choose their own real estate agent and the perception of unbiased representation. While buyers have a higher financial responsibility, they have the freedom to negotiate the commission fee and potentially customize the fee structure to fit their budget.

When it comes to negotiating the commission fee, clear communication, understanding market conditions, and assessing the overall value provided by the agent are key. Mutual respect, fairness, and compromise are crucial elements in reaching a satisfactory commission agreement.

Ultimately, the choice between the builder-paid commission model and the buyer-paid commission model depends on the preferences, budget, and goals of the buyer. Considering factors such as financial capabilities, agent relationships, and the desired level of involvement in the new construction process can help buyers make an informed decision.

Regardless of the commission payment model chosen, it is important for buyers to prioritize finding a trustworthy and experienced realtor who can guide them through the complex world of new construction. Agents with knowledge of the local market, strong industry relationships, and a commitment to their clients’ best interests are invaluable in ensuring a smooth and successful transaction.

In conclusion, understanding and navigating realtor commissions in new construction deals requires careful consideration and open communication. With the right knowledge, approach, and collaboration with a trusted real estate agent, buyers can confidently navigate the new construction process and make informed decisions that lead to their dream home.